Internal vs. External Kung Fu (The Differences and Special Styles)

December 16, 2020 by VAHVA Fitness

The big differences between internal & external Kung Fu and how important both are.

Since we recently released the Internal & External Kung Fu by Jiang Yu Shan, now is a good time to explain the big differences between the two.

External Kung Fu is easy to understand. They are the practices and methods directly related to fighting such as fighting techniques, hardening skill, dirty tactics and so on.

External Kung Fu is the most practical by nature because everything has a clear purpose. You learn punching techniques in order to punch the opponent. You learn to target different vital points to deliver the most damage.

Internal Kung Fu is more about enhancing yourself, your mind, body and movements. It's something that is supposed to support your athletic and fighting ability.

This is why it's a bit silly to think you will fight with Tai Chi which is an internal style. Some techniques may be practical but for the most part it is not a practical external style.

For example, when we talk about rooting, we talk about the ability to ground yourself to hold a better balance and to produce more power with your legs and bodyweight. It's basically ancient stability training (that goes very deep).

Then there are many movements which purpose is to develop the best body mechanics for power production. The purpose is not necessarily to use the movements to fight – the purpose is to develop the body for fighting (or for health).

But real Internal Kung Fu goes deeper than learning how to control your body and generate power with the body mechanics. You will also learn to control your mind and attitude.

Having the proper mindset is a necessary element of fighting which can make or break a fighter. This is why learning to cultivate "controlled rage" is one of the most special parts of Jiang Yu Shan's Internal Kung Fu.

In addition, Internal Kung Fu deals with relaxation, timing, Qi circulation, breathing, rhythm and all the subtle but essential attributes of fighting. All the attributes that clearly exist but are hard to measure. 

Internal Kung Fu is about developing the intangibles. External Kung Fu is about developing the tangibles – the easily seen and measured parts of human performance.

In this sense, MMA is dominantly an external martial art. To complete their training, many modern athletes are using mobility training, massages, psychologists and mindset coaches to help them.

However, in our opinion, many of these aspects are a lot more developed in Internal Kung Fu and Qigong. What is the difference between Qigong and Internal Kung Fu? They are similar but Qigong or Neigong are not necessarily fighting focused.

What is the Best Internal or External Style?

hou quan men

In the past, Jiang Yu Shan talked about how Lohan Quan was the strongest discipline of the ancient Shaolin temple. This is why all Shaolin monks first learned the basics of Lohan Quan.

For Internal Kung Fu, Jiang Yu Shan considers Xinyi Ba the most advanced and highest internal martial art.

Monkey Kung Fu instead was the hardest (in terms of hardening the body) and most cruel style with a strong occult background. 

Basically, different styles have different strengths. To become a complete Kung Fu practitioner, you should learn kung fu as a whole and not focus on just one style. Ultimately, "Shaolin Kung Fu" consists of many different styles and methods.

This is what makes Internal & External Kung Fu by Jiang Yu Shan especially interesting. You are learning many styles and it's all in one package where the different elements support each other. 

In addition to these, Jiang Yu Shan's Trinity System also has the best parts of other styles like Tai Chi which we may cover in the far future.

For decades these methods of Jiang Yu Shan have been hidden in Taiwan alone but what we did is that we basically exported this knowledge from the East to the West to a wider audience.

A lot of these methods and techniques are written in ancient books only with no proper instructions of how to actually practice them. This is why most Shaolin books are almost useless on their own.

However, someone who learned the methods from a generation before can teach you. You can learn at WarriorNeigong.com


Categories


samuli jyrkinen

About the author 

Samuli Jyrkinen

Samuli is the ninja behind the scenes (photography, videography, websites, program platforms and more). He has been training religiously for over a decade and has a firm grasp of physical and mental fitness. You will find our story here.

You may also like

Meridian Brush Massage for Erectile Dysfunction, Energy and Health

Meridian Brush Massage for Erectile Dysfunction, Energy and Health

#21 – Healing & Energy: How Eastern Medicine Will Help You

#21 – Healing & Energy: How Eastern Medicine Will Help You

THE WORST PAIN EVER – Traditional Chinese Slapping

THE WORST PAIN EVER – Traditional Chinese Slapping

The Symphony of Flowers – Qigong, Tai Chi, Flow by Eero Westerberg

The Symphony of Flowers – Qigong, Tai Chi, Flow by Eero Westerberg

Shadowboxing with Monkey Kung Fu Techniques – Monkey Xinyi Ba

Shadowboxing with Monkey Kung Fu Techniques – Monkey Xinyi Ba

Stress & Anxiety: “For thousands of years we had the ability to heal ourselves.”

Stress & Anxiety: “For thousands of years we had the ability to heal ourselves.”
  • MMA are codified rules that are oftentimes conflated with the concept of eclectic systems of martial arts. Likewise, the words internal and external martial arts are oftentimes misused for similar reasons. Taoist martial arts came before Shaolin fighting arts, and these indigenous Chinese fighting arts are known as internal arts because they are native to China. On the other hand, Shaolin fighting systems and Chan Buddhism are influenced by Indian culture, and the Shaolin fighting arts were further developed by Shaolin monks. It’s clear to see that Taoism is a philosophy stemming from China as well as systems like Hsing yi, Bagua, Taiji, Bajiquan, etc. Shaolin is tinged with Indian influences, so the word external is used to describe that Shaolin arts are from foreign influences like Snake Style, Tiger Style, Crane Style, etc.
    Sadly, there are people who actually get mixed up with these concepts. Wei-gong, or strength and conditioning, is oftentimes described with the word external. Martial arts systems with hard and direct attacks are also mislabeled as external styles. However, the word internal is often used to describe systems that involve neigong, which are mind and body meditative workouts involving breathwork and coordinated movement flow. Systems like Taiji teach people how to generate power through fascially driven movement. The body moving as a unit in a smooth manner for health and combat efficiency is the purpose of Taiji. Taiji also teaches people to yield or blend in with attacks to counter with pushes and throws. It’s weird that some people call yielding movements internal rather than soft movements to deflect attacks. I can’t stand the Dantian theory because the concept is unproven. People actually claim that internal styles are systems that cultivate chi. Qigong can be used to develop muscles because some forms of qigong are dynamic tension exercises. Taiji and qigong are simply systems of joint mobility and breathwork.

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
    >